top of page

J. Howard Marshall's Estate and the Case That Reached the Supreme Court Twice

1 day ago
4 min read

J. Howard Marshall II died in August 1995, and the dispute over what he meant to leave behind reached the United States Supreme Court twice, in 2006 and 2011. Few estates produce one Supreme Court decision; almost none produce two. Neither turned on who deserved the money. Both turned on which court had authority to decide, and both grew from the gap between what a man was said to have intended and what his documents did.


Nina Totenberg, NPR's longtime legal affairs correspondent, covered the first decision for All Things Considered on May 1, 2006, in a report titled “Supreme Court Sides with Anna Nicole Smith.” It sets out the collision: a Texas probate court and a federal court reaching opposite conclusions about the same family, an estate reported at roughly $1.6 billion, and a Supreme Court asked not who was right but who had the power to say.



Marshall was a Texas oil businessman who had taught law. He married Vickie Lynn Marshall, known professionally as Anna Nicole Smith, in June 1994 and died the following August. His will and living trust directed his fortune to his son, E. Pierce Marshall, and made no provision for his widow. She contended that he had intended to provide for her through an arrangement discussed but never created, and sued Pierce for tortious interference with an expected gift rather than attacking the will. The posture matters: it was a claim, contested at every stage, and never reduced to a final enforceable judgment.


Two courts took it up at once. A Texas probate court, after a jury trial, entered judgment for Pierce. In California, where she had filed for bankruptcy, a federal bankruptcy court reached the opposite conclusion and entered judgment in her favor worth hundreds of millions. The conflict raised an unsettled question: how far does the judge-made probate exception reach, the rule keeping federal courts out of state probate?


In Marshall v. Marshall, decided May 1, 2006, the Court read that exception narrowly. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote for a Court unanimous in the result: it bars a federal court from probating a will, administering an estate, or disposing of property in a probate court's custody, but not from hearing an ordinary tort claim. Five years later it returned. In Stern v. Marshall, decided June 23, 2011, the Court held five to four, per Chief Justice John Roberts, that although Congress had given bankruptcy courts statutory authority over such counterclaims, a bankruptcy judge, lacking the life tenure and salary protection Article III requires, could not enter final judgment on one. That holding reached far beyond one family, unsettling bankruptcy practice nationwide. Both principals had died by then, Pierce Marshall in 2006 and Vickie Lynn Marshall in 2007; their estates carried on. The Texas judgment stood, and her estate recovered nothing.


For estate planners, the most important point is not the constitutional law. It is the gap at the center of it: an enormous claim resting on an asserted promise no instrument carried out. Whatever Marshall intended, his instruments said otherwise, and instruments are what courts enforce. A spouse omitted from a will is not necessarily without recourse, but that varies sharply by state. In New York, EPTL 5-1.1-A gives the surviving spouse of a decedent dying on or after September 1, 1992, an elective share equal to the greater of $50,000 or one third of the net estate, computed to include lifetime transfers the statute defines as testamentary substitutes. The tools existed. A prenuptial or postnuptial agreement fixing what the spouse would receive, or a trust actually funded during life, would likely have resolved in months what instead took more than sixteen years and two Supreme Court decisions.


None of this requires a fortune. The pattern is ordinary. Someone marries later in life and has adult children from an earlier marriage. He tells his new spouse she will be taken care of, and means it. He tells his children the business stays in the family, and means that too. The documents predate both conversations, or were never revisited after the wedding. When he dies, everyone remembers a promise honestly and differently, and nothing in writing reconciles them.


A well-built plan does the practical work. It converts intention into instruments that operate: a will, a funded trust, beneficiary designations that match rather than contradict them. It addresses a spouse's statutory rights directly, satisfying or waiving them by valid agreement with counsel on both sides. It names fiduciaries who can administer without becoming adversaries. And it is revisited after a marriage, a birth, a sale, or a move; a plan that fit in 1990 may not fit in 1995. The Marshall estate produced two landmark decisions about the limits of judicial power. It never produced an answer to the question underneath them.


Estate Planning Lesson: A promise is not a plan; after death only the instruments speak, so the intention has to be written into documents that actually operate.


bottom of page